Monday, August 3, 2009

Self-disciplined or Stubborn

The behaviors of self-disciplined and stubborn people may seem to be similar because both groups persist on their own set of principles, which are created based on some internalized values. However, I think, the source of internalized values, which could be internal or external, differentiates self-discipline from stubbornness.

Internal values, such as respect, love, care, competence, honesty, integrity, physical and mental health, intellect, etc are associated by human nature. When the principles are rooted in internal values, I refer the insistence on the principal to self-discipline. As internal values seldom change over time, the self-disciplined people usually hold on their principles for long periods.

External values, on the other hand, are coupled with egoistic motives, which are emphasized by external sources such as public eye. I think egoistic motives can be summarized as: “prove” myself or others that “I am right”; while the righteousness can be translated to being respectable, lovable, worthy, competent, smart, knowledgeable, etc.

When the principles are rooted in external values, the persistence is closer to the stubbornness side of the spectrum. External values are frequently changed in nature or priority based on the feedbacks that a person receives from external sources; therefore, the principles, continuously replaced or modified, do not get the opportunity to mature. As a result, the principles that a stubborn person persists on usually lack solid grounds.

From outside, I don’t see a clear line between self-discipline and stubbornness. But, I think that examining the source of values, internal or external, that a person utilizes to create his principles can locate him on the spectrum of self-discipline and stubbornness.

1 comment:

  1. We can't categorize people with shallow/external motives as stubborn. Nature of stubbornness is different from that of having/not having a principle. While I agree with you that external values generate fickle principles, they don't make one synonymous to stubborn.
    Re stubborn peopel: whatever makes a person stubborn (fear of looking weak/indecisive, laziness in hearing or evaluating new ideas, or just sheer close-mindedness) causes a person to stick to an idea (value?) and not be willing to consider/evaluate others. For such person, it does not matter if the ideas are internal or external, deep or shallow.

    ReplyDelete